SPX appears at the center of a diamond cluster and SPY appears at the center of a 3-by-3 square grid.

Before choosing between SPX and SPY options, consider what exercise could leave in your account. SPX options reference the S&P 500 Index and settle in cash. SPY options reference the exchange-traded fund (ETF) that tracks the index, so exercising a call buys shares at the contract's strike price.

In this hypothetical comparison, assume the official Mini-SPX (XSP) settlement value is 775 points and you hold a 770-strike call at expiration. XSP is based on one-tenth of the SPX index level. The five-point difference times the $100 multiplier gives a $500 cash payment. Separately assume SPY shares are worth $775 when you exercise a standard, unadjusted $770 SPY call. You pay $77,000 for 100 shares worth $77,500 at that mark. Both calls have $500 of intrinsic value before premium and fees. SPY exercise leaves a share position to hold or sell.

Use the cash or share outcome to narrow the choice. Then check whether the exact series fits your intended size and whether you can still close it when you need to.

The Alpaca Trading API and dashboard support index-options trading in paper and live accounts, subject to account eligibility and options approval. SPY options are available alongside our other equity options.

Key takeaways

  • SPX and XSP settle in cash. SPY options settle in shares. For a standard, unadjusted contract, SPY exercise or assignment involves buying or selling 100 shares at the strike price.
  • A short SPY option can be assigned before expiration. SPX and XSP use European exercise, which prevents early exercise and assignment. You can still close an index-option position through a trade while its series is open.
  • The exact series determines your last opportunity to trade. AM and PM settlement use different reference prices and trading schedules. Alpaca's order cutoff can come before the exchange closes.
  • Compare costs at the quantity you would trade. One full-size SPX contract carries roughly the same underlying notional as 10 XSP or 10 SPY contracts. Similar notional does not establish equal premium, buying power, or risk.

What cash settlement or share delivery means for your position

For the XSP call in the opening example, the cash settlement is (775 - 770) × $100 = $500. The $100 multiplier converts each index point into dollars. Cash settlement completes the option position without creating a holding in the index's stocks. For a short position, settlement can instead create a substantial cash debit.

For the SPY call, the strike is the price at which its holder has the right to buy the shares. Exercising the call buys 100 shares at $770 each. The $77,000 is the gross exercise payment, and the account must support the resulting share purchase under its buying-power and margin rules. It is separate from the option premium paid to acquire the call.

The $500 comparison measures intrinsic value: how far each call is in the money, multiplied by its contract size. It is not net profit, because the example supplies no option premium and excludes fees. Nor does the example imply that exercising is preferable to selling the call. A closing sale ends the option position without the share purchase.

Share delivery matters on both sides of a SPY option. Exercising a call buys shares; exercising a put sells them. Assignment gives the short position the corresponding obligation: a short call must deliver shares, while a short put must buy them. The 100-share examples apply to standard, unadjusted ETF options; adjusted contracts can have different deliverables.

Early assignment can change the position before your planned exit

SPY options use American exercise, so a holder can exercise on a business day before expiration. If you have sold a SPY option, planning to close it later does not remove the possibility of assignment while it remains open.

Early-assignment risk on a short SPY call can increase ahead of an ex-dividend date, especially when an in-the-money call has little remaining time value. Exercise economics also depend on financing and other costs, so the dividend alone does not establish whether exercise is worthwhile. The OIC assignment FAQ explains the holder's choice and the short position's obligation.

SPX and XSP use European exercise, which restricts exercise to expiration and removes early assignment. The restriction applies to exercise. You can buy or sell the option to close a position while that series is trading. If your intended holding period ends before expiration, the next questions are how much exposure to trade and when the opportunity to close ends.

Match the contract size to the exposure you want

The smaller size of XSP is useful when you want to evaluate cash settlement at a scale closer to one SPY contract. At hypothetical levels of 7,700 for SPX, 770 for XSP, and $770 per SPY share:

Contract Underlying notional per contract Contracts for about $770,000 of notional
SPX 7,700 × $100 = $770,000 1
XSP 770 × $100 = $77,000 10
Standard SPY $770 × 100 shares = $77,000 10

Notional expresses the dollar scale of the underlying exposure. At these levels, a $77,000 target for cash-settled underlying notional fits one XSP contract. One full-size SPX contract is ten times that size. Use the contract count that fits before comparing quotes or fees. Cboe's XSP specifications set its index level at one-tenth of SPX and its multiplier at $100.

The SPY comparison is approximate. The ETF tracks the S&P 500, but trades at its own market price, with dividends and fund expenses affecting its relationship to the index. Matching notional also leaves premium, delta, buying power, and potential loss to be calculated for the actual contracts. Delta estimates how much an option's quoted premium would change for a small move in the underlying, with other pricing inputs held constant. Two positions with the same notional can therefore have different estimated sensitivity to a market move.

Check when you can close and which price sets settlement

Once the size fits, check whether the series lets you trade during the period you intend to hold it. Some index options stop trading before their settlement value is determined. A position left open remains exposed during that interval, with no opportunity to close that contract through a trade.

Standard SPX uses expiration-morning opening prices

The standard AM-settled SPX series expires on the third Friday of the month and ordinarily stops trading at 5:00 p.m. ET on the preceding business day, usually Thursday. That is the end of Cboe's Curb session, an additional exchange session after regular trading hours.

The final settlement value, SET, uses each constituent stock's opening trade on its primary exchange that morning. If a stock does not open that day, its prior-day last trade is used. The stocks do not all open at the same moment, so SET combines prices from different times and can differ from both the prior close and the published SPX level at 9:30 a.m.

If you leave the position open after its last trading session, that opening-price calculation determines the cash settlement. An overnight move can therefore affect the payment even though you can no longer trade the expiring contract.

SPXW and XSP use expiration-day closing prices

SPXW is the root symbol for PM-settled SPX options, including weekly and daily expirations. SPXW has the same S&P 500 Index underlying and $100 multiplier as standard SPX, with settlement based on the expiration-day close instead of expiration-morning opening prices. XSP also uses PM settlement, at one-tenth of the index level.

Expiring SPXW contracts ordinarily trade until 4:00 p.m. ET on expiration day, or 1:00 p.m. ET on a half-day holiday. Expiring XSP contracts ordinarily stop at 4:00 p.m. ET on a normal trading day. Both settle from the official closing prices used to calculate their index settlement values. An option's last traded price is a different input and does not determine that settlement amount.

Alpaca's order window can close before the exchange session

Exchange hours describe when the venue permits trading. Your broker's order cutoff determines when you can submit an order through that account and access channel. Alpaca does not currently support Global Trading Hours for index options. Exchange schedules may include sessions that are not available through Alpaca.

Nasdaq lists SPY options among the classes that normally trade until 4:15 p.m. ET. Cboe also publishes separate hours for eligible SPY options. These are venue schedules. Check the opening and closing cutoffs for your account and access channel before trading an expiring SPY option. Ask how the broker handles an order still working near the cutoff.

Index-option order cutoffs can also come before the exchange closes. Check Alpaca's current cutoff for the exact series, including closing orders, rather than using the exchange's last trading time as your deadline. Exercise-instruction deadlines are a separate broker procedure. If you intend to hold through expiration, confirm the account's exercise and risk-management procedures as well as its order window.

Compare execution costs at your intended quantity

The contract count from the sizing comparison carries into the cost comparison. A spread quoted in index points or dollars per share needs to be converted to dollars for the full position:

quoted_spread_dollars = (ask - bid) * 100 * contracts

In a hypothetical comparison, a 0.10 spread on one SPX contract is $10 wide, as is a 0.01 spread across 10 SPY or XSP contracts. A smaller quoted spread can therefore have the same dollar width at matched exposure. These widths describe quotes, rather than a price at which an order would necessarily fill.

Compare quotes observed at the same time, for the same expiration, at similar moneyness or delta, and scaled to similar underlying exposure. Moneyness describes the relationship between the strike and the underlying price. Matching those conditions makes the comparison more informative while leaving each contract's settlement and exercise differences in view.

For a single-leg order, record the national best bid and offer (NBBO), displayed size on the side you would trade against, and the actual fill. Those observations help distinguish an available quote from the execution your order received. For a multi-leg order, compare the fill with the quoted net price for the whole strategy when available. Separate leg midpoints do not establish a simultaneously executable price for the combination.

Add applicable commissions and exchange, regulatory, and clearing fees at the actual contract count. Ten smaller contracts can carry different charges from one full-size contract. Use the current Brokerage Fee Schedule and reconcile the total with your trade confirmations. The spread calculation alone cannot tell you which position costs less to enter or exit.

Tax treatment can also differ between index and ETF options and depends on the taxpayer and position. Consult IRS Publication 550 and qualified tax advice for the actual position.

Find the contract that matches those decisions

Use contract lookup to find a symbol with the size and settlement terms you chose. To inspect a PM-settled full-size SPX call, search for the SPXW root and verify the individual contract’s expiration and strike.

This read-only request uses a paper account and returns one page of matching contracts. Install requests, set APCA_API_KEY_ID and APCA_API_SECRET_KEY to paper credentials, and replace YYYY-MM-DD with the expiration you want to inspect before running it:

import os
import requests

response = requests.get(
    "https://paper-api.alpaca.markets/v2/options/contracts",
    headers={
        "APCA-API-KEY-ID": os.environ["APCA_API_KEY_ID"],
        "APCA-API-SECRET-KEY": os.environ["APCA_API_SECRET_KEY"],
    },
    params={
        "underlying_symbols": "SPX",
        "root_symbol": "SPXW",
        "expiration_date": "YYYY-MM-DD",  # replace with your chosen date
        "type": "call",
        "status": "active",
    },
    timeout=15,
)
response.raise_for_status()
payload = response.json()

Follow next_page_token by passing it as page_token on the next request, keeping the same filters, until no further page remains. Then refetch the selected contract by symbol or ID. The contract-search reference describes the filters. A live read-only request uses api.alpaca.markets and the live account's credentials; paper and live credentials are separate.

Check the selected record against the decisions already made:

Decision Fields to inspect What to confirm
Series and holding period root_symbol, expiration_date The intended root and expiration. SPX identifies the standard AM-settled series; SPXW and XSP identify PM-settled series.
Right to buy or sell type, strike_price Call or put, and the strike used in the exercise calculation.
Exercise timing style American or European exercise.
Dollar scale multiplier The multiplier used to convert the quote into a contract amount.
Listing availability status, tradable An active, tradable contract. Account eligibility and the proposed order still need separate checks.

The contract record has no dedicated AM/PM settlement field. Interpret the root using the index-option contract mapping, then check the applicable Cboe specifications. The root distinguishes the settlement families in this comparison. Use the full option symbol to identify the individual contract.

Pricing an order takes a separate market-data request. The Alpaca Market Data API provides quotes and trades for listed index-option contracts through the OPRA options feed, subject to the account's data entitlement. Spot SPX and XSP index levels are outside our current market-data offering. A calculation that needs the cash-index level therefore needs an authorized external source and its timestamp alongside the option quote. SPY data describes the ETF, which remains distinct from the cash index and its official settlement value.

Before submitting an order, confirm the current quote, quantity, buying power, accepted order types, price increments, Alpaca's cutoff, and applicable fees for the selected contract and account. The contract lookup establishes which instrument you are inspecting; it does not establish that a particular order will be accepted.

Try the contract lookup in paper

Choose a position size and holding period to evaluate in paper. For the contract you inspect, note the quantity, the last opportunity to close through your account, and the cash payment or share position that exercise or assignment could create.

  • Set up paper access. Sign in to Alpaca and follow the options trading guide for the dashboard or the Alpaca Trading API.
  • Inspect the exact series. Run the read-only contract search and check the record against your intended size, expiration, and settlement schedule.
  • Test the position's handling in paper. If you proceed to a paper trade, follow it through a closing fill or expiration and reconcile the simulated position and cash changes. The paper-trading guide explains the simulation's limits; a paper result does not establish live execution or eligibility.

Before submitting, put the full symbol, contract count, and confirmed closing-order cutoff together. If the size or window misses the plan, check another series before pricing the order. For questions about access, cutoffs, or supported orders, contact Alpaca Support.

Disclosures

This article is for general informational purposes only. It does not provide investment, legal, or tax advice and does not recommend SPX, SPXW, XSP, SPY, 0DTE options, or any strategy. Symbols, prices, positions, and calculations are examples for educational and illustrative purposes only. Tax treatment depends on individual facts. Consult a qualified tax professional.

Certain index options may be subject to additional fees, including proprietary index option, exchange, regulatory, and other transaction-based fees. Fees may vary by index product and are subject to change. Please review the Brokerage Fee Schedule for current fees and additional information.

Options involve risk and are not suitable for all investors. Losses can be substantial and, for some options positions, can exceed the initial amount invested. Read the Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options before trading options.

Alpaca Trading API paper orders are simulated and do not transact in real securities. Simulated fills, liquidity, latency, order handling, fees, and post-trade timing can differ from live markets. This material describes U.S.-listed contracts. Product availability, serving entity, account eligibility, options approval, required disclosures, data coverage, trading hours, order types, broker controls, and pricing can vary by residence, account, and access channel, and they are subject to change. Paper access does not establish live eligibility. Confirm current terms before use.

Alpaca does not recommend any specific security or investment strategy. Users should conduct their own due diligence before making investment decisions. All firms mentioned operate independently and are not responsible for one another's products or services.

The Paper Trading API is offered by AlpacaDB, Inc. and does not require real money or permit a user to transact in real securities in the market. Providing use of the Paper Trading API is not an offer or solicitation to buy or sell securities, securities derivative or futures products of any kind, or any type of trading or investment advice, recommendation or strategy, given or in any manner endorsed by AlpacaDB, Inc. or any AlpacaDB, Inc. affiliate and the information made available through the Paper Trading API is not an offer or solicitation of any kind in any jurisdiction where AlpacaDB, Inc. or any AlpacaDB, Inc. affiliate (collectively, “Alpaca”) is not authorized to do business.

Securities brokerage services are provided by Alpaca Securities LLC (dba "Alpaca Clearing"), member FINRA/SIPC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of AlpacaDB, Inc. Technology and services are offered by AlpacaDB, Inc.

This is not an offer, solicitation of an offer, or advice to buy or sell securities or open a brokerage account in any jurisdiction where Alpaca Securities is not registered or licensed, as applicable.

For additional information and disclosures, see Alpaca's Disclosure Library.